Would Harry Potter or Percy Jackson win in a fight?
I SUMMON THE POTTER HEADS AND SEAWEED BRAINS
So, I found a forum asking if Percy Jackson or Jason grace would win in a fight, and since I am a lover of hp and pjo it made me wonder if Harry or Percy would win in a fight, or just who is more powerful in general.
Percy Jackson is an 18 year old American boy that is the child of Poseidon, the Greek god of the sea. He can manipulate water, speak to sea creatures/horses, and has a sword named Riptide that always appears in his pocket as a pen if he loses it, and becomes a sword when he uncaps it. (And if he puts the cap on the other end of the sword, it becomes a working pen!)
Harry Potter is a 17 year old British wizard that graduated from Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. He was famous from a young age, being the only person ever to survive the killing curse from Lord Voldemort, and has shown his skills as a very advanced wizard for his age, being able to produce a corporeal patronus since the age of 13. He has a wand that is 11 inches, made of holly, and possesses a phoenix feather core.
So, you guys choose! Use the 🪄emoji for Harry, the 🌊 emoji for Percy, and say why!
View hidden comment
wikiHow forums are moderated for quality. Learn more about our moderation policy here.
Submit Answer
I’d go with 🌊 Percy his control over water and superhuman durability give him an edge in a straight fight, but 🪄 Harry’s magic could still surprise him. Honestly, it’d be an epic battle!
View hidden comment
I agree! Harry did beat You-Know-Who, though, which gives him massive points in my book... Though Percy does have control over water, Harry does too! Aguamenta, or however you spell it. I think it'd be pretty close but I think Harry would probably win. Considering how scared Percy was at the beginning of the first PJ movie, too...
View hidden comment
🪄 Harry Potter is a skilled candidate against Percy Jackson. Sure, Percy Jackson is a demigod that withgoes trials and tribulations of his own, but Harry Potter goes against the powerfulest Dark wizard in the Wizarding World, not only by survivng Avada Kedavra, The Killing Curse, but taking down allies of the Dark Lord, such as Barty Crouch Jr, not to mention the destruction of Horcruxes. Can we also mention how Harry Potter uses Expelliarmus, The Disarming Spell of all things, to fend for himself in the Goblet of Fire? Another point to make is that Harry Potter has Dumbledore's Army, the Order of the Phoenix, and the Golden Trio rooted in both associations.
View hidden comment
Percy, all the way, sure Harry has the wand and stuff but Percy has great direction and is friends with Annabeth who always has a plan so their powers mixed together? Unstoppable man
View hidden comment
🪄he made it though with Voldemort, those cranky deatheaters & that toad Umbridge!
View hidden comment
LET'S BE REAL HERE: percy is a DEMIGOD and harry is a WIZARD they both have an equal chance of winning but if Harry just summoned Sebastian from hogwarts legacy to cast Avada Kedavra on him then percy is 100% DONE but if Percy uses his powers fast enough to oblitterate harry with water AND percy can heal himself so WHO KNOWS WHO WOULD WIN??
View hidden comment
🌊 Guys, be real, if Percy loses his sword (WHICH HE CAN'T), then he'll just use his powers. And if Harry tries to use the 'expiliarmus' spell, then AGAIN, Percy will get Riptide back!
View hidden comment
Percy probably but only bc he is literally a freaking demi-god and is a child of the big three. I mean, Harry's powerful, but can he control the water and tame the ocean? But Harry is more experienced in battle so...
View hidden comment
🪄Harry would Definitely win. How could a demigod defeat magic? And Harry has defeated Voldemort Multiple times.
View hidden comment
🌊 Guys be real, Percy has won like 3 wars, taken down literal gods, has more allies than I have brain cells, AND because of his friends and whatnot bro would have more than just command over the sea. but they would likely be on the same side anyway so like🙃
View hidden comment
What’s on your mind? Ask anything.
Get advice and feedback from experts and wikiHow readers just like you.
Ask a Question
